Battery stops working after 3 years despite scheduled replacements BESS Marchent

  • Christian
  • Topic Author
More
26 Mar 2025 04:09 #13972 by Christian
  Hi SAM team,I'm currently modeling a standalone BESS (100 MW / 150 MWh, LFP chemistry) and encountering a persistent issue:
Although I’ve configured battery replacements correctly (tested both “Replace at specified capacity” and “Replace at specified schedule”), the battery consistently stops operating around year 3. After this point:
  • No dispatch occurs,
  • Battery current and cell voltage flatline,
  • Revenue drops to zero,
  • Despite replacement being triggered (replacement flag active, cost accounted for).
What I've already tested:
  • Replacements set at 70% capacity and every 3 years → same result.
  • Battery life model: Cycle and calendar degradation.
  • Tried changing to only cycle degradation → still no activity post-replacement.
  • Manual replacement cost entered under O&M.
  • Energy market and ancillary services configured, system dispatches properly before failure.
  • Analyzed hourly outputs: SOC, voltage, capacity all drop and never recover after year 3.
  • Cell parameters are valid (e.g. 3.2 V / 320 Ah), system runs perfectly in year 1–3.
It seems like after the first degradation-induced replacement, the battery object exists but doesn’t get reinitialized properly, or the dispatch controller stops sending any commands.My suspicion:This might be an internal issue with how SAM handles re-instantiation of the battery bank after replacement in a standalone configuration. Possibly related to degradation + dispatch interaction.Has anyone encountered this before?
Is there a known bug or workaround for standalone battery systems where replacements are ignored or malfunction after a few years?Happy to share the
Code:
.sam
file and CSV outputs if needed.Thanks a lot!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moderators: Paul Gilman
Powered by Kunena Forum