Solar water, residential - Rated system size incorretly calculated

  • gisraelson
  • Topic Author
More
13 Nov 2015 22:44 #3909 by gisraelson
SAM help says the field "Rated system size" is calculated using the formula:
Nameplate Capacity = Total Collector Area × FRta - FRUL × 30/1000

I input:
Total Collector Area = 8.968
FRta = 0.057
FRUL = 2.7

and calculate answer to be 0.430176.

SAM calculates -0.215232 and fails to run simulation. I get error messages. Please fix.
Thank you.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Paul Gilman
More
16 Nov 2015 19:23 #3910 by Paul Gilman
Hello,
Would you mind [url=mailto:sam.support@nrel.gov?subject=Question%20from%20Support%20Forum t=_self]emailing me[/url] your .sam file so I can see exactly what your inputs look like?
Best regards,

Paul.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • nino
More
24 Nov 2015 14:24 #3911 by nino
Hi Paul,

I am having the same issue. I sent a .zsam file to upper mentioned email address. I hope I did not break any rules with this.

Here are user defined collector specifications I used:

Area: 2.5 m2
FRta: 0.7
FRUL: 4

SAM calculates the "Nameplate thermal capacity" to be: 1.45 kWt.

Whereas if one would use the upper mentioned formula from the help file (Nameplate Capacity = Total Collector Area × FRta - FRUL × 30/1000): 1.63 kWt.

I also tried a couple of more examples, and in some cases SAM even outputs a negative value for "Nameplate thermal capacity", the same like in upper reply by gisraelson.

Why is this happening?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • nino
More
25 Jan 2016 10:41 #3912 by nino
Hi Paul.

I have just tested the same custom collector specifications (Area: 2.5 m2,FRta: 0.7, FRUL: 4) on the latest SAM version: "Version 2015.6.30, 64 bit, updated to revision 4". And it calculates the same "Rated system size": 1.45 kW.
Here is the file:
www.dropbox.com/s/5rufduh6atl93ga/swh_rating.sam?dl=0

Does this mean that the mentioned formula from the help file:

Nameplate Capacity = Total Collector Area × FRta - FRUL × 30/1000

is incorrect?
Because it outputs 1.63 kW for the same upper custom collector specifications (Area: 2.5 m2,FRta: 0.7, FRUL: 4).

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Russ Jones
More
09 Sep 2022 17:11 #11435 by Russ Jones
wat this ever answered?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Paul Gilman
More
09 Sep 2022 22:45 #11436 by Paul Gilman
Hi Russ,

I don't think it was. This is about a very old version of SAM before some improvements were made to the solar water heating model.

Best regards,
Paul.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moderators: Paul Gilman
Powered by Kunena Forum